BMI is useless for anyone who lifts, it calls half the gym obese
Community vote
Total Cap — 100% of 1 community vote. Official sources never set this.
Tried-it reports
Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.
Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.
The BMI argument is back on X. Lifters keep posting examples like a 220 lb trainer at low body fat who benches 325 and still scores 'obese,' and saying waist size or body fat checks are the only numbers that matter. The other side, including some doctors in the replies, says BMI works fine for most people because extra weight is usually fat, and the jacked-guy exception is rarer than gym bros think. Useless number, or fine for 90% of people and lifters just hate it?
Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
More claims to call
b/fitness →- 'Winter arc' is just a New Year's resolution that starts six weeks early and dies the same wayb/fitness · Unrated · 1 comment
- You don't need a single supplement to build a great physique, just food and consistencyb/fitness · Legit (2 votes) · 2 comments
- You can out-train a bad dietb/fitness · Probably True (1 vote) · 0 comments
- Skip rest days if you're motivatedb/fitness · Total Cap (1 vote) · 0 comments
Comments (1)
most people saying this are not actually 18% bf lol