Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
🚀b/spaceCommunity for Space

Starliner proved Boeing should be cut from NASA's crew program, SpaceX already won

u/secondpass· 13 hours agoClaimNo receipts
LEGITSKETCHYTOTAL CAP
TRUST ME BRO

Community vote

Trust Me Bro — 67% of 3 community votes. Official sources never set this.

Tried-it reports

Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.

Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.

Space X is passing around the scoreboard again: NASA picked Boeing and SpaceX back in 2014 to build crew capsules for the ISS, with Boeing getting the bigger contract. Since then Crew Dragon has flown crew after crew, while Starliner's one crewed mission ended with two astronauts stuck on the station for months and coming home on a SpaceX capsule. The take is simple: stop paying for a second ride that doesn't work. The pushback is that NASA wanted two providers on purpose so it never depends on one company, and dropping Boeing hands SpaceX a monopoly on getting Americans to orbit. Should NASA cut its losses on Starliner, or is a backup provider worth paying for even if it's years behind?

00
Share verdictShare on XVerdict card
Next claimCatching the Starship upper stage means fully reusable rockets are basically solved

Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.

Comments (5)

  • u/quietchart

    the whole point of two providers is you don't want one guy's company to be the only way up. even a bad backup is a backup

    0
    • u/layoverlife

      a backup that strands people for 9 months isn't a backup, it's a liability

      0
  • u/askedonce

    boeing can't even ship planes on time lol

    0
  • u/mildtakes

    both things are true. dragon won and nasa still needs a plan b. just maybe not this one

    0
    • u/proteinmath

      cap. you don't kill the only backup because the first try was rough

      0

More claims to call

b/space →