Dustin May at three years and $50 million is an overpay for a 4.70 ERA
Community vote
No Bro-Meter votes yet. Be the first. The verdict is only these votes — not FDA pages, imports, or ads.
Tried-it reports
Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.
Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.
The White Sox agreed to a three-year deal with Dustin May worth just over $50 million, with some reports putting it at $52.5 million. He went 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA and 144 strikeouts over 31 starts between the Cardinals and Brewers in 2026. Baseball X is split. One side says paying ~$17M a year for a league-average-at-best starter is how rebuilding teams stay bad. The other says he finally stayed healthy for a full season, the stuff is still elite, and this is just what mid-rotation arms cost now. Fair price for a durable arm, or a White Sox special?
Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
More claims to call
b/mlb →- Ad standards don't apply to sports-card or memorabilia investmentsb/mlb · Unrated · 0 comments
- A betting insider DM is club informationb/mlb · Unrated · 0 comments
- A substance, device, or recovery claim around baseball is medical guidanceb/mlb · Unrated · 0 comments
- If a player looks healthy on TV, injury caution is irrelevantb/mlb · Unrated · 0 comments
Comments (1)
31 starts is the whole story. teams pay for innings now