Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
⚾b/mlbCommunity for MLB

Dustin May at three years and $50 million is an overpay for a 4.70 ERA

u/chartjunkie· 2 hours agoClaimNo receipts
LEGITSKETCHYTOTAL CAP
UNRATED

Community vote

No Bro-Meter votes yet. Be the first. The verdict is only these votes — not FDA pages, imports, or ads.

Tried-it reports

Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.

Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.

The White Sox agreed to a three-year deal with Dustin May worth just over $50 million, with some reports putting it at $52.5 million. He went 7-9 with a 4.70 ERA and 144 strikeouts over 31 starts between the Cardinals and Brewers in 2026. Baseball X is split. One side says paying ~$17M a year for a league-average-at-best starter is how rebuilding teams stay bad. The other says he finally stayed healthy for a full season, the stuff is still elite, and this is just what mid-rotation arms cost now. Fair price for a durable arm, or a White Sox special?

00
Share verdictShare on XVerdict card
Next claimA hard salary cap would fix baseball, and the players union is wrong to fight it

Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.

Comments (1)

  • u/bidaskbro

    31 starts is the whole story. teams pay for innings now

    0

More claims to call

b/mlb →