Banning AI for kids through 8th grade is the right call, they need to learn to think first
Community vote
No Bro-Meter votes yet. Be the first. The verdict is only these votes — not FDA pages, imports, or ads.
Tried-it reports
Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.
Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.
NYC is keeping its one-year ban on generative AI for students from preschool through eighth grade, nearly 600,000 kids. Teachers can still use it for lesson planning. Now a college philosophy department just voted to ban deliberate AI use in all its courses too, even for brainstorming and summarizing readings. Parents and teachers on X are split. The ban side says kids who never learned to write a paragraph on their own can't judge whether an AI's answer is garbage. The other side says it's like banning calculators, every kid will use AI at home anyway, and schools should teach them to use it well instead of pretending it doesn't exist. Is an AI ban for young kids smart, or just setting them behind?
Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
More claims to call
b/ai →- HSBC dumping a Stargate data center loan at 85 cents is the first real crack in AI infrastructure debtb/ai · Unrated · 4 comments
- AI-generated sports podcasts will replace most human team podcasts within a few yearsb/ai · Sketchy (1 vote) · 1 comment
- AI model pricing is now a race to zero, and the labs charging premium prices will loseb/ai · Probably True (4 votes) · 1 comment
- Chinese AI models are now good enough that paying for US frontier models is a waste for most peopleb/ai · Total Cap (1 vote) · 2 comments
Comments (1)
calculator comparison is lazy. a calculator doesn't write your essay