Arch Manning is overrated, and one game-winning drive at LSU doesn't change that
Community vote
No Bro-Meter votes yet. Be the first. The verdict is only these votes — not FDA pages, imports, or ads.
Tried-it reports
Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.
Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.
Edit: posted this in the 4th quarter with LSU up 21-16, and it aged badly. Texas came back and won 22-21 when Manning hit Raleek Brown for a 4-yard touchdown with seconds left. The question still stands though: one clutch drive, or still not a top QB on a night full of picks? Original post: With LSU leading No. 6 Texas late in Death Valley, the game had turned into an interception fest. Per the box score going around at the time, Arch was 13-of-27 for 123 yards, with picks on both sides, a lot of them in the red zone. CFB X is split. One camp says the Manning name has carried the hype for two years and a top-10 QB shouldn't need a last-second drive to beat LSU with a playoff spot on the line. The other says his legs kept Texas alive on third downs, the receivers didn't help, and he delivered when it mattered. Overrated, or overreaction?
Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
More claims to call
b/college-football →- Devon Dampier isn't just a Heisman contender, he should be the frontrunnerb/college-football · Unrated · 1 comment
- Indiana is a real national title contender, not just a nice storyb/college-football · Unrated · 1 comment
- Dabo Swinney is done at Clemson if they lose to 2-7 Georgia Tech at homeb/college-football · Unrated · 3 comments
- Losing to 3-6 Maryland means Luke Fickell should be on the hot seat at Wisconsinb/college-football · Unrated · 1 comment
Comments (8)
123 yards. against LSU. with the season on the line. the name is doing the heavy lifting
Leavitt threw 3 picks too and nobody's calling him a bust. it was a sloppy game on both sides
cap
the third down scrambles were legit though. Texas is way worse without him, which kind of answers the question
he's good, not generational. the hype was always about the last name
LSU's defense deserves more credit than Arch deserves blame
posted with 4 minutes left and it aged like milk lol
three picks and a walk-off TD. both camps get to be right