A sub-.500 division winner shouldn't get a home playoff game, the NFC South proves the format is broken
Community vote
No Bro-Meter votes yet. Be the first. The verdict is only these votes — not FDA pages, imports, or ads.
Tried-it reports
Lived experience sits next to the community vote. Official sources never override either.
Tap a verdict. It counts right away, no sign-up needed.
All four NFC South teams are below .500 at the midpoint of the season, and one of them is still going to host a playoff game in January. NFL X is reviving the old fight: seed the playoffs by record and stop rewarding a team just for winning a bad division. The other side says divisions are the whole point, rivalries matter, and a weak division winner usually gets bounced in the first round anyway. Should the NFL reseed by record, or is the division system fine as is?
Votes and comments are community opinion, not professional advice.
More claims to call
b/nfl →- The Raiders should have started Fernando Mendoza from Week 1 instead of trading for a veteranb/nfl · Sketchy (2 votes) · 2 comments
- The Browns won the Deshaun Watson trade after allb/nfl · Total Cap (1 vote) · 5 comments
- The Falcons are wasting Bijan Robinson by putting the game on Penix's armb/nfl · Probably True (1 vote) · 2 comments
- Kirk Cousins has earned the Vikings starting job for 2027, not just the rest of this seasonb/nfl · Sketchy (1 vote) · 3 comments
Comments (3)
reseed by record. a 8-9 team hosting an 11-6 team is a joke
then why have divisions at all. the 6 games a year vs your rivals are the whole point
it's midseason, someone in that division will get hot. relax